Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty
Housing

Can Labour really build 1.5m new homes? Not without 'bold' and urgent planning reform, experts say

Labour's goal of 1.5m homes by 2029 hits a wall of productivity woes. Bold planning reforms needed...

Photo of houses in the UK with a red bus in the foreground

Labour has proposed a 1.5 million housebuilding target by 2029 (Lina Kivaka/Pexels)

Labour will miss its 1.5m housebuilding target by 2029 due to a “productivity crisis” that does not allow cities to “build an adequate supply of homes”, campaign groups have warned.

The Centre for Cities has claimed that Labour could fall short of its target by at least 388,000 homes, despite proposed planning changes, also claiming that Greater London could fall short of its 2029 target by 196,000, or 60% of its pledge.

The think tank found that based on historic trends, if private development rose to the same level as its strongest ever period, under the current planning system it would still fall 388,000 homes short of delivering the government’s target by 2029.

Centre for Cities claimed that in order to achieve housebuilding targets, a “bolder reform for the planning system” must be made, adding that the government is “faced with a choice either to scrap the green belt completely or remove the discretionary element of the planning system”.

Labour promised 1.5m new homes in order to tackle a housing crisis that has seen private rents skyrocket, house prices out of reach for many and surging homelessness, with the government setting local authorities the goal of building 370,000 homes per year to meet its targets.

Campaigners have also called for more affordable and social housing to be built, with charity Shelter claiming 90,000 social rent homes are needed every year for the next decade to tackle the housing crisis.

Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty
Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty

Labour has not set a public target for the number of social homes it hopes to deliver, however deputy prime minister Angela Rayner has called for a “council house revolution”.

“Rightly, the government has set a bold housebuilding target,” Andrew Carter, chief executive of Centre for Cities, said.

“For the country to achieve it, parts of England would have to reach an 80-year high in housebuilding. This would be a huge positive for the country but the approach has to be much more ambitious.”

Keep reading the journalism that powers our mission

Register free to continue and learn more about the stories, campaigns and the support we provide, helping people facing poverty across the UK.

He continued: “We’re in a productivity crisis. The UK’s big cities are the jobs and productivity engines of the economy but our planning system doesn’t allow – and has never allowed – them to build an adequate supply of homes for everyone that could work there.”

“By removing the discretionary element of the planning system, the UK would bring its planning system in line with most developed economies, remove a big block on housebuilding and enable places to better respond to future rises in demand for homes,” he said.

“We have done wholesale planning reform before and we can do it again… What we can’t do is raise national economic growth – and reduce the strain high housing costs place on people’s spending power – if we don’t address the backlog of missing homes.”

Addressing the Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee in November, housing minister Matthew Pennycook admitted that Labour’s pledge to build 1.5m homes is “going to be more difficult than what we expected” amid a deepening housing crisis.

He said: “We’re very, very candid about this: we knew that if we won the election we would be grappling with a difficult inheritance in respect of housebuilding as a result of the December 2023 changes to the National Planning Policy Framework, which exacerbated a fall in housing supply that had already been triggered by the present market downturn.”

Pennycook added that the younger generation has been “completely locked out of home ownership as a result of the steadily expanding gap between house prices and average earnings”.

“We’ve got millions of low-to-middle income households forced into insecure unaffordable and far-too-often substandard private rented housing. We have 1.3m people languishing on social housing waiting lists and, to our utter shame as a nation, more than 150,000 homeless children right now living in temporary accommodation.

“That is the price we have paid for not being serious about housebuilding rates.”

Do you have a story to tell or opinions to share about this? Get in touch and tell us more. This Christmas, you can make a lasting change on a vendor’s life. Buy a magazine from your local vendor in the street every week. If you can’t reach them, buy a Vendor Support Kit.

Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty

There’s more than one way to make a difference

Big Issue vendors need you more than ever this Christmas.

Recommended for you

View all
The Renters' Rights Act made it illegal to reject tenants on benefits. But it's still happening
Members of ACORN Leeds community union protesting discrimination against tenants in receipt of welfare benefits
Renting

The Renters' Rights Act made it illegal to reject tenants on benefits. But it's still happening

If Andy Burnham is serious about ending rough sleeping, he mustn't overlook people leaving prison
Andy Burnham speaking at his rough sleeping summit in October
Letters

If Andy Burnham is serious about ending rough sleeping, he mustn't overlook people leaving prison

'Care leavers are far more likely to become homeless. As a minister, I want to change that'
Josh MacAlister
Josh MacAlister

'Care leavers are far more likely to become homeless. As a minister, I want to change that'

Prison leaver warns he is days away from homelessness despite Andy Burnham's rough sleeping pledge
A man walking with bags
Homelessness

Prison leaver warns he is days away from homelessness despite Andy Burnham's rough sleeping pledge