Every week in Fact/Fiction, The Big Issue examines spurious claims, questionable studies or debatable stories from the press to determine whether they are fact or fiction. This week The Big Issue asks whether cardboard beds at the Olympics are intended as a measure to stop athletes having sex at the Covid-hit event.
How it was told
The Olympics are here but not as you know them.
The spectator-less sporting spectacular is about to get underway in Tokyo a year late thanks to Covid, and that means stringent measures are in place to halt the spread of the virus in a country where rising cases triggered a state of emergency two weeks before the event.
While the 11,000 competing athletes are expected remain in bubbles during the event, social media theories pointed to other measures to prevent rising cases in the Olympic Village.
Tweeters honed in on the beds – made out of recycled cardboard – suggesting they were a way to prevent athletes from getting extra exercise during the games.
US Olympian Paul Chelimo was among them. He tweeted that the measures were aimed at “avoiding intimacy among athletes”.
Beds to be installed in Tokyo Olympic Village will be made of cardboard, this is aimed at avoiding intimacy among athletes
Beds will be able to withstand the weight of a single person to avoid situations beyond sports.
I see no problem for distance runners,even 4 of us can do😂 pic.twitter.com/J45wlxgtSo
— Paul Chelimo🇺🇸🥈🥉 (@Paulchelimo) July 17, 2021
He added: “Beds will be able to withstand the weight of a single person to avoid situations beyond sports.”
And the “anti-sex bed” theories soon translated into widespread media coverage.
The Sun covered the story with: “MATING MEDAL-LING: Tokyo Olympics using ‘cardboard beds’ that break if athletes have sex to stop Covid spreading in Olympic Village”.
Yahoo! also covered the story as: “Athletes at Tokyo Olympics ‘given anti-sex’ beds to limit spread of coronavirus”.
It also attracted coverage abroad, with Fox News and the New York Post both covering the story in the US. Both ran the headline: “Athletes to sleep on ‘anti-sex’ cardboard beds at Olympic Games amid COVID”.
But is there any truth to the claims or should they be, ahem, debunked?
The decision to make the beds out of cardboard has nothing to do with dissuading sex among athletes, organisers have confirmed. The story has been widely rubbished by several media outlets – though original stories on the ‘anti-sex beds’ remain.
But all were inspired by some investigation work from Irish gymnast Rhys McClenaghan. He gave the beds the bounce test and concluded: “The beds are apparently meant to break at any sudden movements. It’s fake. Fake News!”
— Olympics (@Olympics) July 19, 2021
The official Olympics Twitter account thanked McClenaghan for “debunking the myth”.
Manufacturer Airweave also claimed the beds are “sturdier than wood or steel” after finding the cardboard design could support up to 200kg. The manufacturer added that the mattress is designed in three blocks to allow athletes’ bodies to “fully relax and achieve deeper sleep”.
But the beds are designed to be sustainable, too, and this was something highlighted long before the games as part of an environmental push by organisers.
The Associated Press detailed the designs as far back as in January 2020 in the piece: “An Olympic First: Cardboard beds for Tokyo Athletes Village”. The 18,000 beds at the games will be recycled after the games though a piece on NPR published three weeks before the event questioned just how far the organisers’ green efforts go.
Either way, both stories called into question the accuracy of the ‘anti-sex’ angle before stories surfaced.
It could be argued the social media storm about the beds ties into a wider fascination with sex at the Olympic Village.
Just as at past games, organisers will give out 150,000 condoms at the Olympic Village in 2021. It’s an evergreen story that has greeted every new Olympics since 1988, when organisers gave out contraception as part of global efforts to combat Aids and HIV.
That message has not changed in the current Covid-disrupted games even if the gesture gets tongues wagging about athletes hooking up at the Olympic Village.
While this story was quite quickly and easily debunked, the way in which it was reported – ignoring previous stories – and how stories were left to stand online afterwards leaves a lot to be desired.
Let’s hope this is the only viral story that comes out of a divisive Olympics in Tokyo.
- 18,000 cardboard beds will be supplied to the Olympic Village
- 150,000 condoms will be given out at the Olympic Games
- 8,500 condoms were given out at Seoul’s 1988 Olympics, rising to 450,000 in Brazil in 2016 to combat the Zika virus (International Olympic Committee)