Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty
SPECIAL PRICE: Just £9.99 for your next 8 magazines
Subscribe today
Politics

Barges and military bases more expensive than hotels for asylum seekers: 'Another bad policy'

Controversial use of sites like Bibby Stockholm and Wethersfield base to accommodate asylum seekers will cost taxpayer £46m more than using hotels

Asylum seekers on the Wethersfield base allegedly tried to take their own lives over poor conditions. Image: Nicola David, One Life To Live

The UK government’s use of barges and military bases to house asylum seekers, introduced to reduce the costs of hotels, is costing more than hotels and housing fewer people than expected.

Asylum seekers are being housed in a former RAF base at Wethersfield and the Bibby Stockholm barge. Its initial estimates were that this would be £94m cheaper than hotels. But a new report from the National Audit Office (NAO), published today (20 March), has found they will in fact be £46m more expensive than hotels.

On top of this, the sites are housing fewer asylum seekers than planned. The Home Office had expected the Bibby Stockholm and Wethersfield base to be accommodating a total of 1,875 people by the end of January 2024. Instead they were accommodating just 897, a shortfall of more than 50%.

“This is another alarming example of bad policies being implemented badly at huge financial and human cost. Instead of considering better value and more appropriate alternatives, the government is intent on housing people seeking asylum in unsuitable accommodation costing over a billion pounds of taxpayers’ money to deliver,” said Enver Solomon, CEO of the Refugee Council.

“The reality is that there would be no need to spend exorbitant sums of money on housing people in barges, military bases or hotels if cases were dealt with in a timely manner.“ 

Concerns have also been raised over the safety of asylum seekers living in the “alternative accommodation”.

Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty
Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty

A former resident of the Bibby Stockholm told the Big Issue how internet on the barge was turned off in the wake of the suspected suicide of fellow migrant Leonard Farruku. In an interview, he detailed freezing conditions onboard, with limited access to medical care.

At Wethersfield, asylum seekers were reported to have set themselves on fire over poor conditions.

Future “large sites” plans include former student accommodation in Huddersfield.

“The Home Office has made progress in reducing the use of hotels for asylum accommodation. Yet the pace at which the government pursued its plans led to increased risks, and it now expects large sites to cost more than using hotel accommodation,” Gareth Davies, the head of the NAO, said.  

“The Home Office continued this programme despite repeated external and internal assessments that it could not be delivered as planned. Its plan to reset the large sites programme makes sense, and the Home Office should reflect on lessons learned from establishing its large sites programme at speed and improve coordination with central and local government given wider housing pressures.” 

The Home Office has been raiding the foreign aid budget to pay for asylum accommodation, with around 80% of the £2.3bn spent on hotels in 2022 coming from the overseas aid budget. It has warned that the bill for accommodation could hit £11bn.

Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty

READER-SUPPORTED SINCE 1991

Reader-supported journalism that doesn’t just report problems, it helps solve them.

Recommended for you

View all
There's no trust left in the world. How can we get it back?
Trust

There's no trust left in the world. How can we get it back?

Nationalisation, buses and homes for rough sleepers: This is what Andy Burnham's Britain would look like
Andy Burnham with Big Issue vendor Colin
Politics

Nationalisation, buses and homes for rough sleepers: This is what Andy Burnham's Britain would look like

Mad King George or Keir Starmer? Jane Austen fans on the Regency era ideas that can save Britain
Jane Austen

Mad King George or Keir Starmer? Jane Austen fans on the Regency era ideas that can save Britain

Russia is 'a threat to the whole world', warns Ukrainian war hero: 'Do not let the world forget'
graves of soldiers
Ukraine war

Russia is 'a threat to the whole world', warns Ukrainian war hero: 'Do not let the world forget'

Reader-supported journalism that doesn’t just report problems, it helps solve them.

Every day, Big Issue digs deeper – speaking up for those society overlooks. Will you help us keep doing this work?