Advertisement
Social Justice

Campaigners slam Priti Patel’s ‘flawed and dangerous’ plan to x-ray asylum seekers to verify their age

Scientists will consider how the UK could verify the age of asylum seekers using methods healthcare workers said are “unethical”

Priti Patel’s plan to use x-rays and CT scans to prove asylum seekers are the age they claim to be has been branded “flawed and dangerous”.

The home secretary announced the formation of a new scientific advisory committee which will consider methods used in other countries such as Finland and Norway which examine a person’s teeth and bones when they are seeking safety.

This is to cut down on the practice of “single grown adult men, masquerading as children” to access schools and extra services and support “through deception and deceit”, Patel said. Many asylum seekers arriving in the UK do not have passports or documentation to prove their age.

But when the idea was reported last year, experts including the British Dental Association blasted the plans as “inappropriate and unethical” and warned dentists could be accused of “criminal battery” to take x-rays of a person without a specific medical purpose.

Patel’s committee will consider a “range of scientific methods” for estimating a person’s age according to their accuracy and reliability, as well as ethical and medical issues.

If an asylum seeker’s age is called into question it is not currently permitted for them to be physically examined, instead being interviewed by social workers. But in its announcement, the government referred to methods in France which include x-raying the fusion of the collar bone, teeth and wrists to ascertain age.

Advertisement
Advertisement

People arriving in the UK after fleeing danger elsewhere will have to consent to being examined, according to the plans, but the Home Office warned refusing tests could “[damage] the person’s credibility” in the eyes of the government.

“To say there are concerns to be had about this is underselling it spectacularly,” Daniel Sohege, director of human rights advocacy group Stand For All, tweeted in response to the announcement.

Even physical examination methods currently used in other countries are only accurate within two years of a person’s age, he added, and can be particularly inaccurate for people of colour because the bulk of research on size and age has been done into white people’s growth and development.

Basing the use of “flawed and dangerous” scientific age assessments on “disingenuous arguments” puts children at risk and would likely benefit the trafficking gangs Patel says she is targeting through the widely-condemned Nationality and Borders Bill, Sohege added. 

The home secretary said she would change UK legislation to “give the British public confidence that we will end the overt exploitation of our laws and UK taxpayers”.

The proposals will end “many of the blatant abuses that have led to our immigration and asylum system being abused by those with no right to be in our country,” Patel said.

“It is a fact that two thirds of age dispute cases have found that the individual claiming to be a child is actually over the age of 18. 

“I have given more resources and support to local councils to ensure that they apply vigorous and robust tests to check the ages of migrants to stop adult men being automatically classified as children.”

Advertisement

Every copy counts this Winter

Your local vendor is at the sharp end of the cost-of-living crisis this Winter. Prices of energy and food are rising rapidly. As is the cost of rent. All at their highest rate in 40 years. Vendors are amongst the most vulnerable people affected. Support our vendors to earn as much as they can and give them a fighting chance this Winter.

Recommended for you

Read All
Here's when people will get the £150 disability cost of living payment
Cost of living crisis

Here's when people will get the £150 disability cost of living payment

100 people making a difference for future generations in Wales
Big Futures

100 people making a difference for future generations in Wales

All the cost of living help available from the government, energy companies, councils and charities
Cost of living crisis

All the cost of living help available from the government, energy companies, councils and charities

Time to Talk: 'Don't let your debt and mental health struggles bury you'
Time to talk day

Time to Talk: 'Don't let your debt and mental health struggles bury you'

Most Popular

Read All
Lauren Layfield: 'Normal men, innocent men' and me
1.

Lauren Layfield: 'Normal men, innocent men' and me

Here's when people will get the next cost of living payment in 2023
2.

Here's when people will get the next cost of living payment in 2023

Where to find grants for furniture and carpets in 2023
3.

Where to find grants for furniture and carpets in 2023

Scotland aims to cut car use by creating '20-minute neighbourhoods' in net zero push
4.

Scotland aims to cut car use by creating '20-minute neighbourhoods' in net zero push