Advertisement
Opinion

‘Institutional thoughtlessness’: A catchy new name for the old boys club

How can a government of ex-private school kids understand what people on the margins go through?

I’ve become very keen on watching Ed Balls cook. Turns out the former Shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer knows his way around a kitchen. At home, he takes on most of the cooking. He’s very good with a Mexican-style breakfast. I suspect most of us will not sample Balls’ breakfast.

All this is only clear because he and a number of other celebrities, including Ed Byrne and one-time Big Issue columnist (top of her CV) Rachel Johnson, are on a TV show. It’s celebrating the best of home cooks. Like a MasterChef for those with profile but limited ability. Though Rachel is very confident with venison.

It is curious to see the arc Balls has followed, from Oxford and Harvard, to big-brained policy wonk influencing how we all live while advising then-PM Gordon Brown, to going Gangnam Style on Strictly, and now here, fretting about the crispiness of his roast potatoes.

During the show he has become, briefly, a signifier, indicative of a change in behaviour. ‘Look, LOOK, he could have been Chancellorbut he sorts out the cooking at home. See, SEE, men are takingmore responsibility.’

This is greeted, in my home at least, with a polite, but knowing, shrug. Ed is an outlier.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Support for women when they’re doing the heavy lifting, like home-schooling during lockdown, isn’t what it should have been

And lockdown isn’t making things a whole lot better in the balance of work at home.

According to a committee of MPs in a report on the impact of Covid on men and women, government policies are skewed towards men. They called it “institutional thoughtlessness”. It means support for women when they’re doing the heavy lifting, like home-schooling during lockdown, isn’t what it should have been.

MP Caroline Nokes, the chair of the committee behind the report, also said something significant on publication. There was a “very blokey mentality at the top” of government, which had suffered from “the predominance of single-sex education round the Cabinet table”.

This must impact on much beyond what the report focused on. How could a government of wealthy men educated at the country’s top private schools really share a sense of what people living right on the margins go through? They could visit and make the right noises, but ultimately they won’t have any lived experience.

The ongoing awarding of vital contracts to friends of ministers doesn’t remove the sense that those at the bottom are not a priority during decision-making, unless there is political gain.

It’s not clear how this gap will be bridged. Education to allow social mobility is one way. But then you fall down a rabbit hole trying to convince that social mobility, as it stands, is anything but a zero-sum game – if you step up, that means there’s one fewer chance for somebody else.

Instead, this must be about raising the floor for everybody. It’s looking at the 20 recommendations Nokes’ committee made, ensuring help for women in work and the home. It means government making sure they bring through, and listen to, people who have lived very different lives. This can only happen if they make a point of it happening.

Why not take bold steps?

Otherwise, we’re going to be spending much more time checking out Ed’s stuffing.

And that can only go so far.

Paul McNamee is editor of The Big Issue 

Advertisement

Bigger Issues need bigger solutions

Big Issue Group is creating new solutions through enterprise to unlock opportunities for the 14.5 million people living in poverty to earn, learn and thrive. Big Issue Group brings together our media and investment initiatives as well as a diverse and pioneering range of new solutions, all of which aim to dismantle poverty by creating opportunity. Learn how you can change lives today.

Recommended for you

Read All
The Secret Civil Servant: We come up with solutions and ministers ignore them
The Secret Civil Servant

The Secret Civil Servant: We come up with solutions and ministers ignore them

In a tent in Devon, having a field day
John Bird

In a tent in Devon, having a field day

Afghan refugees have the right to a warm welcome
Enver Solomon

Afghan refugees have the right to a warm welcome

We're spending more time in the garden, where nothing is rosy
Paul McNamee

We're spending more time in the garden, where nothing is rosy

Most Popular

Read All
Oil giants Shell and BP have been handed £700m of taxpayer cash despite bumper profits
1.

Oil giants Shell and BP have been handed £700m of taxpayer cash despite bumper profits

What are the risks of Don't Pay UK? We asked a leading lawyer
2.

What are the risks of Don't Pay UK? We asked a leading lawyer

How broken is the UK's public transport? I spent all day on buses to find out
3.

How broken is the UK's public transport? I spent all day on buses to find out

Sadiq Khan's Right to Buy-back scheme leads to return of 1,500 council homes
4.

Sadiq Khan's Right to Buy-back scheme leads to return of 1,500 council homes

Keep up to date with the Big Issue. The leading voice on life, politics, culture and social activism direct to your inbox.