Advertisement
Opinion

Our most beautiful art treasures hide a multitude of sins

We’re still feeling the consequences of Victorian inequality – a browse through our museums reflects a society built on imperialism and hubris, and unearned wealth

The Cast Courts at London’s Victoria and Albert Museum are like a greedy grabbing-up of some of the most important sculptures and pieces of architecture in the world. But in fact it’s not a grabbing-up. Because the great array of artworks are plaster-cast copies of the real thing. It’s a hoard of big bits of the works of – among others – Michelangelo. If you can’t get to Florence to see the giant David standing in the Galleria dell’Accademia, pop along to the V&A and you’ll not be disappointed by the vast replica, looking like the real thing. 

I went to the V&A last weekend because I wanted to look again at a place that meant so much to me as a youngster. Drawing Michelangelo those many Saturdays or Sundays in the 1960s was like a whistle-stop tour around great sculptures; the fact they were not the real McCoy meant nothing to me. 

Exterior of the North Transept of the Crystal Palace, London (Steel engraving, 1851)
Credit: World History Archive / Alamy Stock Photo

The sense of crowding history and art into this vast room is amplified today because thousands more people visit now. A tide of people greets you, whereas I remember it as a bit of a dusty old place where I would be left to wander about, almost on my own. I loved the kind of mad array in the whole museum, as if little thought has been given to its arrangement, and that feeling is still there. It’s like a storehouse, not necessarily carefully arranged. I’m sure the curators would disagree but I get the feeling of creative jumble: it’s too, too much to take in at any one visit. 

But of course the crying shame about most museums is that much of it is the booty of empire, got as the spoils of being the top dog in the 19th century. Our network of museums would not pass an audit if a just and honest acquisition policy was adhered to. But then the past was not that equitable. And museums are a part of the past. 

The V&A owes its creation to the Great Exhibition of 1851 which was put up just north of the museum, in Hyde Park. Millions came from all over and its effect, with the recently opened railway lines, was socially enormous. It pushed tourism up the ladder of polite things to do. And it helped also to put industry and the arts foremost in people’s minds. But it did have a side that I have banged on about for decades: it showed that Great Britain, once the workshop of the world, was losing out to European – and American – innovation. Most of the goods made by British businesses were consumer goods for the growing middle class. There was little evidence of new innovation in business. The new industries were being developed, among other places, in the German states – Germany being not yet a country. Britain was becoming a nation of yesterday’s inventions. Investors were making their money in the colonies and through people shopping. Not in new science and technology. 

Top-dog status in the world meant largely military and empire prowess, not technological invention. Britain was laying down many of its later problems, when it became increasingly a land of cheap jobs and an underpaid, often under-skilled, workforce. A multitude of British jobs often left people on the edge of poverty, with politicians and trade unionists struggling to up the wages of the working poor. But also consider the great wealth of the Victorian world that was derived from the opium trade. And the fights that GB had to have, particularly with China to keep open the drug dens servicing the Chinese poor. 

Advertisement
Advertisement

We have yet to recover from the damage done to humankind by the Victorian world of business and pleasure. The law of unintended consequences stalks the pages of history. And a visit to any of our great museums should be a history lesson in what was done in our name in decidedly unenlightened times. Their artefacts enrich our grasp of the world, but there’s always the sobering thought that they were poorly obtained. 

The Cast Court; copyright Victoria and Albert Museum, London

I assure you I had not intended to end this piece with a complaint against imperialism, but it kind of drifted that way. At least the Cast Courts at the V&A can rightfully claim they left everything behind intact when they created the replicas and didn’t use their top dog status to purloin product. Our under-invested educational sector, our vast amount of poorly paid jobs and our wealthy getting a lot of their wealth from property all conspire to create poverty for the many. And that, alas, owes much to our Victorian background. 

For too long we seem to have been lulled into a false sense of security that’s grown out of a highly biased view of the past. We have come out of a dark past that needs the light of day to expose it. More to understand it, I would suggest, than to slag it off. 

But look about the world and just notice how many of our current problems have grown out of that disturbing past. The past comes to bite us and museums like the V&A are a true storehouse of wonder; and history to reflect on. 

John Bird is the founder and Editor in Chief of The Big Issue. Read more of his words here.

This article is taken from The Big Issue magazine. If you cannot reach your local vendor, you can still click HERE to subscribe to The Big Issue today or give a gift subscription to a friend or family member. You can also purchase one-off issues from The Big Issue Shop or The Big Issue app, available now from the App Store or Google Play.

Advertisement

Every copy counts this Winter

Your local vendor is at the sharp end of the cost-of-living crisis this Winter. Prices of energy and food are rising rapidly. As is the cost of rent. All at their highest rate in 40 years. Vendors are amongst the most vulnerable people affected. Support our vendors to earn as much as they can and give them a fighting chance this Winter.

Recommended for you

Read All
Developments in space travel and technology need to benefit everyone
Opinion

Developments in space travel and technology need to benefit everyone

New laws could make it easier to arrest journalists. Here’s why that matters
Press freedom

New laws could make it easier to arrest journalists. Here’s why that matters

When Sam Delaney needed to sort his mental health, the solution was unexpected – sincerity
mental health

When Sam Delaney needed to sort his mental health, the solution was unexpected – sincerity

What it's like being a doctor in our broken NHS
NHS Crisis

What it's like being a doctor in our broken NHS

Most Popular

Read All
Glen Matlock: 'I wish John Lydon stood by Anarchy In The UK's words'
1.

Glen Matlock: 'I wish John Lydon stood by Anarchy In The UK's words'

Louis CK’s sold-out show at Madison Square Garden proves there’s no such thing as cancel culture
2.

Louis CK’s sold-out show at Madison Square Garden proves there’s no such thing as cancel culture

Beyoncé fans enraged as some tickets cost more than a month's rent
3.

Beyoncé fans enraged as some tickets cost more than a month's rent

Here's when people will get the next cost of living payment in 2023
4.

Here's when people will get the next cost of living payment in 2023