Books

In 1923, Edith Thompson was hanged for a murder her lover committed

Author Laura Thompson says the beautiful and ambitious woman couldn't count on public support

Crowds outside Holloway Prison, where Edith Thompson (1893 - 1923) is to be hanged for the murder of her husband, Percy, London, 9th January 1923. Edith Thompson was jointly convicted with her lover, Frederick Bywaters, who was hanged at Pentonville Prison on the same day. (Photo by Hulton Archive/Getty Images)

In January 1923 Edith Thompson, aged 29, and her lover Frederick Bywaters, aged 20, were hanged for the murder of her husband. Bywaters had stabbed Percy Thompson during a scuffle on a street close to the couple’s home in Ilford. Although Edith was present it was never suggested that she played a physical part in the killing, but she was found guilty of conspiracy: of foreknowledge and incitement.

As sentence was pronounced she screamed: “I am not guilty! Oh God, I am not guilty!” Meanwhile a Home Office file, held under the 100-year rule and prematurely opened, recorded that on the morning of his execution Bywaters said: “Mrs Thompson knew nothing about the crime.”

It was not the first time that he had made this statement. The actual evidence against Edith Thompson was pretty much non-existent, but it made absolutely no difference. The presumption, from the first, had been that hers was the hand that had metaphorically guided the knife. Almost everybody wanted to think this, and sympathy was almost entirely for Bywaters. As the magistrate at the initial hearing put it: “He was exposed for many months to the malign influence of a clever and unscrupulous woman eight years older.”

It was an absurd simplification – the handsome merchant seaman Bywaters was no innocent – but it was the narrative that everybody craved, and none more so than other women. The author Rebecca West was a self-proclaimed feminist; nevertheless her belief in the sisterhood did not extend to the notorious Mrs Thompson, whom she dismissed as “a shocking piece of rubbish”. Everything about Edith invited prejudice from one quarter or another: she was disturbingly sexy, she was a self-centred career woman (a manager in a wholesale millinery firm) and – like Lady Macbeth, that other great inciter – she had no children. She did not know her place, and she did not fit.

It was not exactly a pleasure to write about

Even today, she would arouse strong feelings among the commentariat. Bywaters would still, for some, be viewed as the plaything of his rapacious cougar. Back in 1922, meanwhile, she had no chance whatever. This lower-middle-class East London girl – who had sought to shape her own destiny, as far as was possible within the twin circumscriptions of class and gender – was fated to become one of those sacrifices that society periodically demands.

I first read about the Thompson-Bywaters case as a teenager. Since then it has been under my skin. It was not exactly a pleasure to write about (although it seems presumptuous to say that I found it painful, given what the protagonists endured) but I wanted desperately to do so. The story is not unknown; however mine is the first account to have used all the information previously held under the 100-year rule. This includes eyewitness reports of Edith Thompson’s execution, about which rumours – notably that she was pregnant  – have abounded ever since.

The contents of those two giant files at the Public Records Office, which I read over several weeks in a sealed room, were fascinating, terrible, at times near-unbearable. There was an overwhelming sense of authority at its most obdurate and immovable, hellbent upon the cool destruction of a woman who was guilty of folly, of failing to understand the fiery nature of a very young man, even – yes – of a kind of incitement, but of nothing that inhabited the stark sphere of a capital charge.

Rex-v-Edith-Thompson-

We are only too familiar with the miscarriage of justice. To my mind the story of Edith Thompson is the worst of the lot. Of course the execution of a 20-year-old boy was an outrage, although Frederick Bywaters had at least done the thing of which he was accused.

The desire to reprieve him was strong, but that would have meant reprieving her as well, and the national mood – high on prurient excitation about hanging the first woman for 15  years – did not want that at all.

And here is an irony. Edith remains alive, quite gloriously so, in the remarkable and beautiful letters that she wrote to Bywaters. Yet it was these same letters that – as the detective who headed the investigation wrote – “played a great part in hanging her”. Firstly, they contained a number of references to poisoning her husband. He was demonstrably unharmed in this regard, but it was a dangerous game to have played, and viewed as irrefutable evidence of guilt. Worse yet, the letters held the qualities that perplexed and affronted the public about Edith: the romantic allure, the troubling air of pagan eroticism. “He has the right by law to all that you have the right to by nature and love…” It seems today like the act of a dystopia, to condemn a person to death for their words; although the urge to condemnation does not go away, it merely mutates. 

Rex v Edith Thompson by Laura Thompson is out on March 8 (Apollo, £25) 

Join The Ride Out Recession Alliance

The Ride Out Recession Alliance (RORA) will develop and implement practical steps and solutions to prevent families losing their homes, and help people remain in employment.

Learn More

Support the Big Issue

For over 30 years, the Big Issue has been committed to ending poverty in the UK. In 2024, our work is needed more than ever. Find out how you can support the Big Issue today.
Vendor martin Hawes

Recommended for you

View all
Top 5 books about the British seaside, chosen by crime writer William Shaw
Books

Top 5 books about the British seaside, chosen by crime writer William Shaw

The Other Valley by Scott Alexander Howard review – the moral conundrums of coming of age
Books

The Other Valley by Scott Alexander Howard review – the moral conundrums of coming of age

From castle walls to Banksy: How graffiti has given us the writing on the wall throughout history
Graffiti

From castle walls to Banksy: How graffiti has given us the writing on the wall throughout history

Fragile Animals by Genevieve Jagger review – a captivating and original gothic novel
Books

Fragile Animals by Genevieve Jagger review – a captivating and original gothic novel

Most Popular

Read All
Renters pay their landlords' buy-to-let mortgages, so they should get a share of the profits
Renters: A mortgage lender's window advertising buy-to-let products
1.

Renters pay their landlords' buy-to-let mortgages, so they should get a share of the profits

Exclusive: Disabled people are 'set up to fail' by the DWP in target-driven disability benefits system, whistleblowers reveal
Pound coins on a piece of paper with disability living allowancve
2.

Exclusive: Disabled people are 'set up to fail' by the DWP in target-driven disability benefits system, whistleblowers reveal

Cost of living payment 2024: Where to get help now the scheme is over
next dwp cost of living payment 2023
3.

Cost of living payment 2024: Where to get help now the scheme is over

Strike dates 2023: From train drivers to NHS doctors, here are the dates to know
4.

Strike dates 2023: From train drivers to NHS doctors, here are the dates to know