The Covid-19 pandemic has hit the economy hard. Companies have had to close their doors throughout lockdowns and they have forced through cost-cutting measures to stay afloat – including using fire and rehire tactics against workers.
For some firms, fire and rehire has been part of the strategy to survive through Covid disruption and the response from unions and employees has made worker rights a hot topic during the pandemic.
This is why the practice is proving controversial, and why the Westminster government is facing calls to ban it.
What is fire and rehire?
Fire and rehire involves an employer threatening an employee with the loss of their job if they do not sign up to new terms and conditions of an employment. It is typically used to impose changes on a workforce when they generally do not agree to the changes.
It can also refer to employees who are made redundant and forced to reapply for roles.
The practice can see employers look to make changes to working hours, pay and benefits or other working conditions.
Is fire and rehire legal?
Under current rules, there is no specific legislation to outlaw fire and rehire.
That is why there were calls from anti-poverty charities as well as MPs from across the political spectrum for an Employment Bill in May’s Queen’s speech to legislate against it. An Employment Bill featured in the previous Queen’s speech in 2019 but the omission this time around does not mean legislation will not arrive during the current parliamentary session.
The Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (ACAS) advises employers that dismissing employees to force a change in contract should be used as a “last resort”.
Before taking the action, ACAS recommends the employer considers whether the changes are “absolutely necessary” and considers the impact on wider morale and the risk of legal action.
If the employer decides to press ahead it should follow a fair dismissal procedure, give the employee enough notice and offer a right of appeal. If an employee has worked for the employer for more than two years and feels as though they’ve been unfairly dismissed, there is a chance they may be able to make a claim to an employment tribunal.
Business minister Paul Scully has indicated that the UK government does not wish to bring in “heavy-handed legislation” to outlaw the practice.
How widely is fire and rehire used?
There have been several fire and rehire rows throughout the pandemic, with some still ongoing. In research published in January 2021, the Trade Unions Congress (TUC) said as many as one in 10 workers had faced the threat of fire and rehire during the pandemic.
The TUC poll found young workers, working-class employees and BME staff had been most affected. Nearly a fifth of 18-24 year-olds said they had been threatened with fire and rehire while BME workers were nearly twice as likely as white workers to have faced the practice.
TUC General Secretary Frances O’Grady said: “Fire and re-hire tactics have no place in modern Britain and must be outlawed.”
Who has faced fire and rehire?
Fire and rehire tactics have affected several sectors with the most high-profile cases coming at British Airways and British Gas.
With flights largely scrapped due to the pandemic, British Airways cargo workers based at Heathrow Airport faced the threat of fire and rehire until Unite the union came to a deal with BA bosses in January.
There was no such positive resolution at British Gas. Hundreds of British Gas engineers were sacked in April after refusing to sign up to new terms which would see them work a longer working week, and more unsociable hours for no more money, amounting to a pay cut.
The GMB Union held 43 strikes before the dispute ended in mass sackings and engineers warning the row may not be the last time workers fall foul of fire and rehire. British Gas engineer Martin Glover told The Big Issue: “Hopefully our strikes have brought fire and rehire to the public’s awareness. I think it’s a bit too late for us now but hopefully what we have done will help other people who will be going through the same situation.”
Current vacancies...Search jobs
There was better news for Manchester bus drivers from Go North West’s Queens Road depot. Their 82-day strike, one of the longest-running industrial actions in the UK, ended in May with the firm taking the action off the table.
Unite general secretary Len McCluskey said: “This dispute should also send a clear and unequivocal message to all employers that Unite will never accept fire and rehire for our members – that we will do everything in our power to prevent it, and we will win.
“The government itself has described fire and rehire as a `bully boy practice’ but the only way to guarantee UK workers are protected from this pernicious practice that’s ripping through our workplaces is for the government to follow the lead of other European countries and ban it once and for all.
“Urgent action is needed to strengthen the UK’s weak laws because it’s simply too easy for employers to make brutal changes to contracts, sometimes taking thousands of pounds from workers’ wages.”
We regard fire and rehire as unacceptable, and will continue to make that point and seek further means of redressPrime Minister Boris Johnson
But Unite’s action against lettings platform Goodlord ended after three months in May with nine employees dismissed from the firm.
Referencing staff had been due to strike indefinitely until Goodlord decided to part ways with nine employees, who had claimed new contracts would result in a £6,000 pay cut.
Goodlord strongly disputed accusations that they were using fire and rehire tactics. They told The Big Issue the sacked employees were on temporary contracts due to expire and had been offered full-time roles at the company.
In a statement, a Goodlord spokesperson told The Big Issue: “Our colleagues were offered a range of options to bring this dispute to an end. Unfortunately, none of the options put forward were taken up by these nine individuals, who instead indicated an intention to continue indefinite strike action.”
However, the Living Wage Foundation confirmed Goodlord had been stripped of Living Wage Employer accreditation after employees in London saw their pay fall below the London living wage during the dispute.
We are fighting cases of #fireandrehire across the country. We are also campaigning for Government to step up & #stopfireandrehire for good.
Please join us by emailing your MP to ask them to call an end to this unfair & damaging practicehttps://t.co/FlF8tEEjTU pic.twitter.com/P9QEMwiXjl
— NASUWT (@NASUWT) May 18, 2021
Other disputes are ongoing, including at Jacobs Douwe Egberts’ factory in Banbury where workers are currently taking strike action over fire and rehire.
Workers at Weetabix factories in Kettering and Corby will go on strike in June 2021 after Unite workers backed a walkout on every Wednesday through to September over the threat of pay cuts imposed through fire and rehire.
The disruption could result in shortages of the cereal across the UK, according to Unite regional officer Sean Kettle: “Strike action will inevitably cause serious disruption to the production of Weetabix and will lead to shortages in shops as the strike progresses.
“This strike can still be avoided if the company takes the threat to fire and rehire its workers and the prospect of huge pay cuts off the table and instead enters into sensible negotiations with Unite.”
Retailer Argos is also on a collision course with workers over proposed new contracts, according to reporting from The Mirror. Staff will reportedly see a shake-up to pension contributions and annual leave that will see them worse off, reports said.
Teaching union NASUWT has said it is fighting the practice across the country.
What does the government say?
The Westminster government has said on several occasions that fire and rehire is not acceptable.
Prime Minister Boris Johnson told MP Anna McMorrin in the House of Commons in January: “We regard fire and rehire as unacceptable, and will continue to make that point and seek further means of redress.”
However, business minister Paul Scully indicated that the government will not be seeking to introduce legislation to crack down on the practice.
Speaking in a debate on employment rights in the House of Commons on June 8, Scully said: “The Government wants to send a clear message to employers: even if your business is facing acute challenges, all other options to save jobs and a business should be exhausted before considering the dismissal and re-engagement of staff.
“I believe that we can achieve this working in partnership with businesses and workers, without heavy-handed legislation.”
What do experts say about fire and rehire?
While employers are facing cash difficulties due to the pandemic, using fire and rehire tactics is a “dangerous game”, according to Professor Nick Bacon of City, University of London’s Business School.
He told The Big Issue firms like British Gas and British Airways “used the opportunity to drive down terms and conditions in their sector” during the pandemic and it could take a long-term toll on their profitability.
Professor Bacon said: “I think that is pretty challenging for organisations which rely very heavily on customer service. Customer service requires committed and engaged employees and if you are going to change their contracts you lose that engagement and commitment, that leaves you with a lot of ground to build up in terms of customer service.
“It’s a dangerous game those organisations are playing, they are concentrating on shorter gains rather than long-term labour hoarding and treating their employees well.”
Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (ACAS) also published a report on fire and rehire in June 2021 in a bid to find out how widespread the practice has become in the UK.
Calling the report a “fact-finding” exercise, ACAS reported that contributors told them “the practice has become increasingly prevalent both in recent years and during the pandemic”.
ACAS also found a “shared anticipation” the fire and rehire will continue to be used more frequently once “the government’s furlough and COVID-related business support initiatives are wound down, especially if the economic recovery is slow”.
What can I do to oppose fire and rehire?
One way to take on fire and rehire is to join a union in the sector where you work. Joining a union allows workers to organise and bargain collectively, potentially improving negotiation power.
The Trades Union Congress’ website features a union finder to help you find a suitable union for the sector where you work.
Fire and rehire can also be opposed by signing a petition. There are several ongoing petitions but the parliamentary petition is the only one that can force a debate in parliament with 100,000 signatures. Sign that one here. Other petitions are also available on Organise and the GMB Union’s website.
You can also write to your MP to ask them to support efforts to ban fire and rehire. Full details on how to contact your MP can be found here.
The Big Issue is offering free training and job search help to anyone who needs it with our new RORA Jobs and Training Toolkit. Sign up to receive a free three-month digital subscription to The Big Issue, access to dozens of free or discounted online training courses and the ability to search hundreds of thousands of jobs.
Career tips and advice from our Jobs and Training series:
- How to change your career – A step-by-step guide
- Employee rights in the UK: Everything you need to know
- Redundancy rights: Everything you need to know
- How to write a CV that will get you a job
- Job interview questions: What to ask and how to answer
- CV templates: Free downloads for job application success
- What to do if you’ve been made redundant
- Apprenticeships: Everything you need to know
- Apprenticeships: How to get a job once your placement ends
- Redundancy: Surviving the mental health impact of losing your job
- 11 tips to help you make the most of online learning
- How to go self-employed in the pandemic
- Budgets, benefits and tax breaks: Money advice for young people after Covid
- The top job adverts to look out for as lockdown eases