“Activists who plan actions will be thinking how they can respond to that change in geopolitical reality. The media is looking in a different direction, but also activists are intentionally strategising because they’re facing a different global political problem.”
Much of the attention gained by climate activists is a result of their intentionally disruptive actions: slow-walking in roads, or blocking motorways. These disruptive and radical protests can increase support for moderate groups, a study published in October found.
In January 2023, Extinction Rebellion dramatically announced “we quit”, stepping back from disruption. The subsequent “Big One” protest, which focused on getting more people engaged with the group, failed to generate as much attention as smaller, disruptive actions, one academic found.
Continue reading for free
Registration is free and takes less than 30 seconds.
Our supporters make Big Issue’s work possible. Join us to see the impact we’re having together and discover more ways to help people facing poverty access income, opportunity and support.
Now, the media is often looking the other way, says Sam Nadel, the interim director of Social Change Lab, a think tank looking at the impact of protests. The cost of living crisis took up much of the attention and momentum afforded to climate activists. “It’s still happening, it’s just getting less coverage,” says Nadel. “There’s signs of diminishing returns from those types of actions, in terms of media coverage,” he added. “That’s making activists think.”
Anti-protest laws and strict prison sentences are having an impact, says Abrams, but not necessarily putting protesters off. “There is a culture of public silence prior to any big action being taken, which means that when movements are in the planning stage, they’d be less loud than they were a couple years ago,” he says, adding that activists will likely “price in” the prospect of a prison sentence.
But for small groups, like Just Stop Oil, there can be a “depletion effect”, Abrams adds: “The impact of the prison sentences is to be taking people who are committed activists out of interactions with other people they could work with. They’re not available to train, plan, or give inspirational talks. There are only so many people in a movement’s pool of personnel who will be available.”
Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty
Could it all be building to a 2019-like moment, seen as a high point of climate protest, where masses took to the streets for Extinction Rebellion actions and concern for the environment shot up the political agenda?
As Trump’s climate denial focuses minds, this could be a catalyst for action, says Abrams. “People will inevitably be disheartened but also left grasping for an efficacious way to make a difference in a globalised climate struggle. Movements will be looking for a way to provide that way forward,“ he says.
Any big spark needs a set of conditions to be just so, adds Nadel: critical moments, points of fracture, a clear problem, with iorganised groups ready to spring into action and recognised figureheads like Greta Thunberg.
“Combined with populism, with the clear lack of interest in pursuing any actions from Trump and any other climate denying leaders around the world, you do have the ingredients for a new wave of climate activism around the world. Whether that does lead to a moment like 2019 is really hard to say,” says Nadel. “The ingredients are definitely there.”
Do you have a story to tell or opinions to share about this? Get in touch and tell us more. Big Issue exists to give homeless and marginalised people the opportunity to earn an income. To support our work buy a copy of the magazine or get the app from the App Store or Google Play.