Housing

Family of 5 accused of 'deliberately' living in a tiny studio flat win High Court battle

Southwark council had refused to provide priority housing for the family.

Campaigners celebrate high court win against Southwark Council

Campaigners celebrate the housing win against Southwark Council.

A man living with his wife and three children in a tiny studio apartment has won a High Court battle against Southwark Council, after the local authority prevented the family from accessing priority housing.

Southwark Council had told Milton Laines Roman in 2018 that his application for housing in the borough would not be prioritised, claiming that his family’s move into overcrowded accommodation was a “deliberate act”.

The council suggested that, as Laines Roman had willingly moved into a property that was not big enough for his family, he had moved into statutory overcrowding by choice. 

This was a position the council maintained for years, despite its own allocation policy indicating that the nature of the property’s overcrowding should have meant the family were prioritised for council housing.

Yesterday (May 24), the High Court overturned the council’s decision to refuse to provide priority housing, suggesting that a council housing applicant cannot cause their own statutory overcrowding if they are unable to afford other, more suitable housing in the area.

Southwark Council told The Big Issue it is “sorry [they] got this wrong” and is working with the family to help them meet their housing needs.

Laines Roman said that he moved his family into the small flat as they were unavailable to afford anywhere else to live in the area.

He had moved to the UK from Ecuador in early 2016 to look for work, and settled on Southwark as his sister lived in the borough. His family joined him in October that year.

After the family were evicted from their shared one-bedroom flat in Brixton a month later, they spent time searching for suitable, reasonably-priced accommodation in the borough with no luck. They moved into the studio apartment soon after.

“I had to move to this flat. When we looked at other places the agencies asked us for many months’ rent in advance. I couldn’t rent a bigger place because it was too expensive,” Laines Roman said in a statement following the High Court decision.

According to estate agent Foxtons, the average rent cost for properties in Southwark is almost £700 per week. Laines Roman said the cheapest suitable property he could find in the borough cost £1,600 a month, which was hugely beyond the family’s budget.

“Southwark have constantly disbelieved me and my wife and tried to make us feel as though we were in the wrong,” he added. “We feel so relieved that the judge has understood the situation we were in and has agreed that the council has broken the law in denying us housing.

“I hope that this can bring an end to the overcrowding we have faced for over five years.”

The family only became aware of the support available through the council in 2018, after learning about local housing campaign group, Housing Action Southwark and Lambeth (HASL).

The group, which helped the family to apply for housing and appeal the council’s continued rejections, said it was “overjoyed” by the High Court ruling.

“This is yet another victory won by some of Southwark’s most vulnerable private renters against a Labour council who have been set on blaming the victims of the housing crisis,” said Elizabeth Wyatt, a representative for HASL.

“HASL, over 30 other community groups, and hundreds of Southwark residents have been campaigning for years in support of families in overcrowded housing and reminding the council that the root causes of the housing crisis are a desperate shortage of family-sized council homes, high private rents, and benefit cuts.

“We hope the council will finally listen.”

Sam Tippet, from the Public Interest Law Centre (PILC) which represented the family at the High Court, said the case was indicative of the wider housing crisis.

“The root cause of our client’s problem is the extreme shortage of suitable council housing. In Southwark there are over 16,000 people on the housing register. The chronic underfunding of adequate housing for people on low incomes is a political failing at a local and national level,” he said.

“In London in particular, this issue disproportionately affects migrant communities and people of colour.

“Only a commitment to building more council housing will prevent more families being pushed into the intolerable situation that our client has had to endure.”

Councillor Darren Merrill, cabinet member for council homes and homelessness, said: “The judge ruled that the council was wrong to assess the family as deliberately overcrowding themselves. We respect the decision of the court and we are carefully reviewing the judgement.

“We should not have described them as deliberately overcrowded, and we are sorry we got this wrong. We’re continuing to work with the family to provide them with support, to ensure their housing needs will be met.”

Support our vendors this winter and beyond

If you can't visit your local vendor on a regular basis, then the next best way to support them is with a subscription to the Big Issue. As a social enterprise, we invest every penny we make back into the organisation. That means that with every subscription, we are supporting people in poverty to get back on their own two feet.
Vendor martin Hawes

Recommended for you

View all
'An amazing U-turn': Home Office drops bid to allow asylum seekers to live in unsafe housing
Asylum seekers risked being left
Immigration

'An amazing U-turn': Home Office drops bid to allow asylum seekers to live in unsafe housing

Landlord Tory MPs are trying to 'gut' protections for private renters, analysis shows
no-fault evictions
Renters Reform Bill

Landlord Tory MPs are trying to 'gut' protections for private renters, analysis shows

Prince William to build social housing in his back garden to help end homelessness
Prince William launches Homewards
Homelessness

Prince William to build social housing in his back garden to help end homelessness

Mum with disabled daughter facing homelessness as council refuses help: 'She'll have a breakdown'
disability, housing, eviction
Homelessness

Mum with disabled daughter facing homelessness as council refuses help: 'She'll have a breakdown'

Most Popular

Read All
Renters pay their landlords' buy-to-let mortgages, so they should get a share of the profits
Renters: A mortgage lender's window advertising buy-to-let products
1.

Renters pay their landlords' buy-to-let mortgages, so they should get a share of the profits

Exclusive: Disabled people are 'set up to fail' by the DWP in target-driven disability benefits system, whistleblowers reveal
Pound coins on a piece of paper with disability living allowancve
2.

Exclusive: Disabled people are 'set up to fail' by the DWP in target-driven disability benefits system, whistleblowers reveal

Here's when UK households to start receiving last cost of living payments
next dwp cost of living payment 2023
3.

Here's when UK households to start receiving last cost of living payments

Strike dates 2023: From train drivers to NHS doctors, here are the dates to know
4.

Strike dates 2023: From train drivers to NHS doctors, here are the dates to know