It’s unsurprising that getting more people to become homeowners is a Tory priority.
At the 2019 General Election, 57 per cent of owner-occupiers and 43 per cent of mortgage holders voted Conservative compared to just 22 per cent and 33 per cent respectively for Labour.
Recent housing announcements like the Right to Buy extension to people living in housing associations or the ‘benefits to bricks’ plans to allow people to use housing benefit to go towards a mortgage have been aimed at turning so-called generation to rent to generation buy.
But 50-year mortgages cannot tackle the issue of affordability, according to Freddie Poser, a director at housing campaigners Priced Out.
He cites a continued failure to build enough affordable homes – the government has recently been evasive on its 2019 manifesto commitment to build 300,000 homes a year in England – and the future risks of loading debt on to the next generation.
Big Issue Foundation
Donate to support vendors today
Your gift today will mean Big Issue vendors will get the support they need to progress forward in life. You will be supporting vendors in key areas including housing, finance, mental health and employment.
“I think it’s an absolutely terrible idea. It’s just another example of the government punting down the road the real issue, which is the lack of supply in the housing market,” said Poser.
“We haven’t built enough homes, everyone knows that now. The government also knows it is politically poisonous to try and fix that issue. Things like the Right to Buy for housing associations and any expansions to help to buy are demand side issues of what is fundamentally a supply crisis.
“I can’t see how this will help. I think, even before you take into account the effects of the policy, the idea that you should have to sign your unborn potential children up to debt in order to pay off a mortgage is particularly weird. It’s also quite clearly going to inflate prices further rather than tackling the core of the issue.”
The cost to future generations is also a concern to Graham Taylor, of mortgage broker Hudson Rose, without a guarantee that the loans would remain affordable in the long-term.
“On the face of it, this seems like a great idea, but the problem remains that the loan would need to be affordable for all the original applicants and also the children who inherit it,” said Taylor.
“Otherwise, the children could risk inheriting a liability they are unable to manage which, when secured against your home, has catastrophic consequences.”
Scott Taylor-Barr, financial adviser at Carl Summers Financial Services, said 50-year mortgages do not deal with another barrier to home ownership – how wages have not kept up with house prices.
House prices have risen more than 10 per cent in the last year at a time when wages have fallen in real terms as rising inflation and cost of living has swallowed up pay rises.
“I feel that Boris Johnson is coming at this from the wrong direction,” said Taylor-Barr.
“It is not the mortgage market that is preventing people from becoming homeowners, it is the cost of property in relation to people’s earnings.”