Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty
Opinion

Why we need to press pause on the plastic straw ban

The Scottish Government's proposed ban on businesses and public transport using plastic straws is the final straw for disability campaigners – but Pam Duncan-Glancey says working together could produce better, greener solutions

“Why not focus on real problems, like availability of disabled toilets?” “Can’t disabled people just bulk buy plastic straws?” “I’m pretty sure this isn’t some ‘anti-equality agenda’. And anyway, what did disabled people do before plastic straws?”  These are just some of the comments we’ve had since our campaign group One in Five wrote to Kate Forbes MSP, asking that the #finalstraw campaign – forcing businesses and public transport providers to cease provision of reusable plastic straws – be paused.

First, let me say that I support all efforts to reduce and stop the use of non-recyclable plastic, of all sorts, including straws (which I rely on to drink).  However, as with all policy, this has to be done in a way that both serves to protect our environment for future generations and does not disproportionately affect disabled people. A solution that is greener, and fairer, is possible.

The problem is that straws have disappeared from cafes, bars, pubs, restaurants and the like, almost overnight. Many have no alternatives on offer and of the ones which do, many are unsuitable. Paper straws can’t be used for hot drinks, they disintegrate and they become soggy, and this can be a risk of choking. Metal straws are dangerous for people who have difficulty controlling their bite – and of course they can heat up to high temperatures in hot drinks. Paper and metal straws are also inflexible, which can be difficult for some people, depending on their impairment, and can make it easier to spill drinks. Reusable straws in public places are not hygienic – we’ve all seen the chewed, teeth marked reusable plastic straw: yum, enjoy your drink!

Lastly, bulk buying them to carry around is passing yet another cost onto disabled people, and is not suitable if you accept that society bears a responsibility to make the world accessible for disabled people.

What this means is that not only do we have to deal with ‘real problems’ like access or availability of toilets, but now we can’t have a drink in public, in a convenient and dignified way. I can see how the issue of straws can seem insignificant, especially when you consider the serious and consistent breaches of disabled people’s human rights that persist. However, for many this could be the straw that breaks the camel’s back; in a life that is already full of discrimination and inconvenience, this is yet another hurdle.

One in Five’s aim is not to derail efforts to remove plastic straws, but to simply ask that whilst suitable, bio-degradable alternatives are sought, the common plastic straw is still available for those who need them.

Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty
Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty

Disabled people are innovative by design, we can help make a case that will serve us all and create the greener and fairer world we all want to live in.

Usually when we move to another product, eg from diesel to electric cars, we do so over time. Now, I’m not pretending replacing cars is as simple as straws, nor am I saying that phasing out plastic straws should take nearly as long. But the principle is there – make Scotland greener and fairer. That’s all we ask.

So please, to all the outlets out there who serve drinks to the public, please keep a small number of straws on offer for those who rely on them.

To the manufacturers of biodegradable plastic – please develop a viable alternative, soon.

To the Scottish Government, please put things in place to speed up the development and then deployment of them.

And lastly, to our friends and colleagues in the green lobby, disabled people are innovative by design, we can help you make your case, for straws and more. A case that will serve us all well and create the greener and fairer world that we all want to live in. And if that’s not a ‘real issue’ worth fighting together for, I don’t know what is.

Pam Duncan-Glancy is a disability, equality and human rights consultant and co-founder of the One in Five Campaign. Pam tweets @GlasgowPam

Our 2020 Impact Report

The Big Issue has given more than £1 million support to Big Issue vendors struggling due to the lockdown restrictions. To mark the significant milestone, we have published an impact report, documenting the seismic shift the organisation has undergone in the past 12 months.

View Report
Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty

READER-SUPPORTED SINCE 1991

Reader-supported journalism that doesn’t just report problems, it helps solve them.

Recommended for you

View all
Marmot principles should be applied to government departments for ending poverty
John Bird

Marmot principles should be applied to government departments for ending poverty

The first-ever World Vacant Homes Day is putting focus on bringing empty homes back into use
boarded-up empty homes
Adam Cliff and Tom Gilligan

The first-ever World Vacant Homes Day is putting focus on bringing empty homes back into use

When are you putting the heating on?
old woman adjusting heating thermostat
Your views

When are you putting the heating on?

Mounjaro for all! Will Wes Streeting's plan for weight loss jabs on the NHS really work?
Paul McNamee

Mounjaro for all! Will Wes Streeting's plan for weight loss jabs on the NHS really work?