The fallen F matters. The cough matters. The internecine Tory feud matters. The Boris circus, those Brexit across-the-barricades catcalls, the great goon show that is modern politics – it all matters.
It matters because it sucks up oxygen, takes our focus and becomes the only game in town. It’s hypnotic. But it doesn’t make the looming cloud any smaller. We can’t make the truth go away by refusing to address it. The government, the rest of us, we’re looking at the shiny paint on the car and not admitting the engine is held together with frayed string.
The great looming cloud growing this winter is Universal Credit. And it’s noxious.
Universal Credit is, in theory, a good idea. Simplifying the baroque benefits system was necessary. The idea that work is better than non-work and a reliance on state benefits is laudable. For Iain Duncan Smith, architect of Universal Credit, it was an ideological crusade that couldn’t fail. People would take control of their welfare income, then better route maps would be created to carry them to the verdant plains of work. So far, so idealistic.
Vendors buy magazines for £1.25 and sell them for £2.50. They are working and need your custom.
Trials started. But even when red flags appeared, on it went. Then, IDS left his place at the head of DWP for the good ship Brexit, and nothing changed. The overspend on the computer system didn’t derail Universal Credit, nor the increasing stories of withheld payments, debt spirals and fears for people at the very bottom of the pile.
The government looks either focused on its internal battles, or their army of civil servants is away from the daily grind and onto Brexit. Either way, this is not a good plan
Each new applicant faces a delay in payment of six weeks. This is supposed to reflect the delay in pay when entering the job market. But if there are no personal savings, nothing to plug the gap, where is the money coming from? What point is this making? Especially for the sick or disabled.
This, of course, is, before you ask more probing questions as Labour MP Jess Phillips has done, about the good sense of universal credits for everyone in a household going into the pocket of one person. If that person has a gambling or a booze problem, or wants to punish their partner, new problems are being stored up. Call it the law of unintended consequences, but admit that it’s there.
Each new applicant faces a delay in payment of six weeks. What point is this making? Especially for the sick or disabled
Last week, The Big Issue founder John Bird said he feared Britain was heading for the worst street homelessness levels for 20 years. If Universal Credit is rolled out nationwide in its current form those numbers will inevitably spiral. If there is no money and no support network, the street opens. The financial cost to the country trying to put things back together will be staggering. The human cost will be terrifying.
Yet, the government looks unable to change tack. It looks either focused on its internal battles, or their army of civil servants is away from the daily grind and onto Brexit. Either way, this is not a good plan.
If Theresa May is busy and wants some advice, she could look over here. Big Issue Invest has canny thinking around helping those previously disenfranchised, about credit and about how to invest to really help communities grow.
If the PM, however long she remains, hasn’t totally forgotten her pledge to speak for the poorest and those just about managing, now’s the time to put up her hand. Before a problem turns into a full-blown crisis.