Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty
Opinion

How a journey on the train suggests living in the real world is not for everyone

A train journey makes John Bird reflect on modern times

Commuters on the District Line, pre-mobile phone

Commuters on the District Line, pre-mobile phone. Image: Bill Bachmann / Alamy

The train filled up quickly, rather desperately, as it came late into the platform. Earlier I had been listening to a politician using the English language as a kind of guard against understanding. Almost like a kind of unarmed combat, words thrown at me to cheat me of an answer. Unarmed combat that I was losing. Oxygen got drawn out of the room as the babble of defence cornered me. I left parliament empty headed. And then later I had to hurry for a crowded rush-hour train, everyone hungry for a seat.



One seat was available. That was occupied by a man’s bag. I requested the seat and the man looked at me, as my mother would say, ‘as If I had shat my pants’. He stood, took the bag and placed it easily on the rack above and made way for me to sit. He returned to his phone. I sat and found that the man opposite me had his feet spread out to where my feet should go on the floor. I asked to be excused but got no answer and pushed my feet towards his. He looked up from his phone as if he also thought I had emptied my bowels in front of him. For an hour we all travelled together in a unity of disharmony. A disgruntling, troubling event.

I should say that there was no sign of drunkenness or physical incapacity. The men around me looked healthy specimens, well-made and professional if one can gauge such a classification in these days when professionals don’t wear suits and ties. I would say that what united the three men around the table on the train – yes, there was a third man who was greedily eating a large bag of crisps – was dissatisfaction. Yet all of them had their phones before them that opened them up to a whole alternative world. A world that was denied earlier generations who only had a newspaper to read, full of stale news from the day before. Grubby might be the word to describe the old days when newspapers dominated. And you probably had to wear a shirt and tie and polish your shoes until they looked like mirrors before you were allowed into work. 

Insular might be the operative word. Earlier in the day I had been on the London Underground surrounded by more schoolchildren than I believed possible crammed into the carriage. I had a seat and waited for the third stop where I was getting off. When I stood to leave I realised I was in the last carriage and the train door didn’t open. I then had to force my way through the length of the carriage to get to the next set of functioning doors. I shouted out “Excuse me” and pushed forward and, like the Red Sea parting for the Jews, I got through with boys calling out “Let him through.” Breathlessly I got off the train and a hooray went up at my success.

Read more:

What a contrast to my next piece of transportation! From the joyful to the truculent, insular and selfish. I took out my notebook and continued writing my notes for the day, my brain unshrunk by AI making any decisions for me. With only the paper before me and not the whole world of the phone as a way of filling time. Or whatever it is that people do on their phone.

Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty
Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty

All of this has been achieved for us by innovators and skilful users of technology, and programmers able to create a new scientific language to enable us to have every book ever written now digitised before us. I myself write on my phone but I could also have Disney join me so long as I could pay. Walt Disney, who after the Second World War when I was a child would provide many of the cartoons for our ‘Saturday morning pictures’. A weekly feast, a harbinger of the future, of the shape of things to come when distraction would become the most dominant human industry. When you could have your own Saturday morning pictures to yourself; and every day and every night so long as you had the device.

I ask, did the internality provided by phones mean on my journey home last week that my fellow passengers could not conceive of the needs of a fellow passenger? Could not conceive that outside their digital bubble there was actually a real world? And the man with the spreading feet did not realise that the floor of the train was not just for him?

This process, where everyone has become their own aristocrat, I first noticed on the King’s Road Chelsea when I was in my 20s. Usually abusive behaviour was portioned out in society to my underclass of people. We were the louts and the ruffians. But then I saw middle-class drunkenness and poor language from my social betters. ‘Watch your phucking self you cuunt’, coming from the mouths of people who could have been a Boris Johnson or a David Cameron.

Tell the next Prime Minister to end the housing crisis

1 in 153 people in England is experiencing homelessness. Will you sign Big Issue’s letter to the next PM?

Of course then, post-war, more assertive misbehaving amongst the upper classes became known to us. The Bullingdon Club at Oxford University and their wild antisocialism with the aforementioned Johnson and Cameron as members. Trashing life for high spirits. The power of privilege.

Individualism seems to be the most prized possession of modern times; and the businesses of today are moulding themselves around our requirements, feeding our needs. To keep us glued to consuming product, through our thirst for separation.

I went to bed full of thoughts of the politicians who didn’t know how to relate to the real world. And the real world full of people wrapped up in their own world. And then the image of the screaming, happy youngsters enjoying their time on a crammed underground.

It was a very disjointed day. Very much like this piece – forgive me.

John Bird is the founder and editor-in-chief of the Big Issue. Read more of his words from our archive.

Do you have a story to tell or opinions to share about this? Get in touch and tell us more

Change a vendor’s life.

Buy from your local Big Issue vendor every week – and always take the magazine. It’s how vendors earn with dignity and move forward.

You can also support online:
Subscribe to the magazine or support our work with a monthly gift. Your support helps vendors earn, learn and thrive while strengthening our frontline services.

Thank you for standing with Big Issue vendors.

Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty

Do you know how Big Issue 'really' works?

Watch this simple explanation.

Recommended for you

View all
Gary Stevenson: Why I’m taking over the Big Issue to call for a wealth tax
gary stevenson in the Big Issue office
Gary Stevenson

Gary Stevenson: Why I’m taking over the Big Issue to call for a wealth tax

How data is the gift that keeps giving for big business
Opinion

How data is the gift that keeps giving for big business

I was homeless and battling addiction. Now I run a charity helping others get through their struggles
Robert Smith

I was homeless and battling addiction. Now I run a charity helping others get through their struggles

The moment I realised that Americans were taking Trump seriously
Steven MacKenzie

The moment I realised that Americans were taking Trump seriously