Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty
News

Watch University Challenge to pick a uni, say researchers

Graduate earnings are more closely linked to their university's number of appearances on University Challenge than to official government data

Winchester, England - October 16, 2014: Mother and graduate daughter embrace and the University of Winchester graduation ceremony after attending the service.

People often ask if university degrees have the same value they once did. Best not consult government figures about how lucrative a course at a certain university could prove to be – but pay attention to how many of its alumni appeared on University Challenge.

Researchers at the University of Surrey have found that graduates’ incomes at age 29 showed a stronger link with their university’s appearances on the BBC quiz programme in the past 25 years than with Teaching Excellence Framework (TEF) data.

Under TEF assessment, universities are awarded either gold, silver or bronze status to indicate their standard of teaching.

The method has attracted controversy in the past, with doubt cast on how accurately it measures the quality of education.

The metrics are based on student feedback on the quality of the teaching they have received, the employment or academic status of graduates, and dropout rates.

Professor Marco Mongiello, who worked on the study, said the team found no correlation between TEF gold and silver ratings with higher earnings.

Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty
Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty

And colleague Dr Katarzyna Zdunczyk went so far as to say that “parents and sixth-formers would be better off if they simply went for universities that appear more often on University Challenge.”

“By relying on superficial measures of student experience and outcomes, TEF misinforms potential students about what matters when choosing a higher education institution.”

Image: iStock

Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty

READER-SUPPORTED SINCE 1991

Reader-supported journalism that doesn’t just report problems, it helps solve them.

Recommended for you

View all
Anti-abortion groups have received funds from the UK government and National Lottery
A chancellor of the exchequer holding the briefcase containing the government's budget.
Abortion

Anti-abortion groups have received funds from the UK government and National Lottery

Reversing Right to Buy may sound radical. But it could fix the housing shortage
Peter Apps

Reversing Right to Buy may sound radical. But it could fix the housing shortage

Labour deputy leader Lucy Powell on benefit cuts, landlords and taking on Farage: 'There's no quick fix'
Lucy Powell in House of Commons
Politics

Labour deputy leader Lucy Powell on benefit cuts, landlords and taking on Farage: 'There's no quick fix'

What is the truth about crisis pregnancy centres? The anti-abortion facilities creeping across Britain
a woman sitting on a couch
Abortion

What is the truth about crisis pregnancy centres? The anti-abortion facilities creeping across Britain