Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty
Employment

Milburn Review: Could disability benefit cuts for young people cost the government more than it saves?

Former health minister Alan Milburn has recommended that disability benefits be replaced with a youth allowance for some young people. But could that cause more harm than good?

Young people standing against a wall

Young people could lose financial support. Image: Pexels

Disability benefit claimants had a few months of relief with talk of cuts paused after Keir Starmer’s government was forced to make a humiliating U-turn. But now, in proposals slammed by charities and sure to cause deep anxiety for disabled people, disability benefits are back on the chopping board.

Andy Burnham’s government is considering stripping young people of their financial support following a landmark, government-commissioned review into youth unemployment by former health minister Alan Milburn. It recommends that disability benefits be replaced with work and training for people under the age of 25.

Milburn argues that those with the most severe needs would be protected and continue receiving their monthly personal independence payment (PIP), but the majority would have to apply to receive one-off payments for specific purposes.

Read more:

If the government went ahead with these proposals, young people would no longer receive the health element of universal credit – which has already been sliced in half for new claimants – or PIP. Instead, they would receive a new youth allowance in universal credit.

Work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden told the BBC: “[Milburn] is proposing that for someone who has a disability that means they can never work, they will actually get more support than they get at the moment. 

Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty
Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty

“He’s also proposing that if you have a disability where you need extra costs, you’ll get an extra cost benefit. And for the rest, he is proposing support into education, work or training.”

McFadden then confirmed “there will be people in the future who will not get what they will get today”, although the government is yet to confirm that it will follow Milburn’s exact proposals for disability benefit cuts for young people.

The news has already caused alarm among the disabled community. 

Keep reading the journalism that powers our mission

Register free to continue and learn more about the stories, campaigns and the support we provide, helping people facing poverty across the UK.

One mother said: “I’m worried for my son, because he’s never going to be able to work. He doesn’t have the capacity and he doesn’t understand what work is. The thought that he could have money taken away from him is really worrying.”

Her son is 14, autistic, non-verbal and has learning disabilities. He attends a specialist school and requires full-time care. His mother believes that he will never be able to work and that he is unable to understand the concept of work.

If he has his benefits stripped away, she says, it will not help him into employment – it will merely plunge their family into deeper financial difficulties.

“I think [my son] will live with me for the rest of my life. He won’t leave home. And at the moment, we’re only just hanging on financially month to month,” says the mother, who has been supported by disability charity Sense.

“The price of everything has gone up so much in the past few years. The electricity bills in my house are off the scale and our water bills are huge too. Nappies and wipes and extra laundry detergents and changes of clothes for Ayman are all so expensive. 

“The idea of our household getting less in future frightens me. It would be difficult to live and pay the bills.”

Another mother, Lorraine Griffin, whose 14-year-old and 15-year-old boys both have autism and attend a specialist school, also fears for their futures.

She said: “The money we receive in disability benefits is everything to us. It means we can live – it means we can go out, put food on the table, and meet our basic needs.

“I hate to think what would happen if we were forced to live on even less. It wouldn’t just be difficult — it would be impossible.”

There are currently almost a million young people not in employment, education or training (NEET). The Milburn review was commissioned by the government because these levels of youth unemployment were widely considered a crisis.

There is broad agreement that young people need more support to get into work, but should that come at the cost of young people with health conditions getting financial support?

Big Issue has reported extensively on the impact that disability benefit cuts could have on claimants and we have repeatedly heard that the loss of financial support can worsen people’s physical and mental health, pushing them further away from the workplace and putting greater pressure onto the NHS and social services, which comes at a cost to the country.

“The evidence is clear that cutting financial support increases poverty, worsens health and makes it harder for young people to engage with support,” said Lucy Schonegevel, director of influencing and impact for Action for Children.

“Existing claimants will understandably be worried about the reports. There is currently not enough detail available to understand who would gain, who would lose out, and what protections would be in place for those facing the greatest barriers.

“We share the ambition of helping more young people thrive, participate and move towards employment. However, no young person who is already struggling should be made poorer as a result of reforms intended to improve their opportunities.

“As these proposals are developed, the government must ensure it listens to the experiences of young people themselves and ensures any changes are accompanied by the support, protection and investment needed to help them succeed.”

The publication of the Milburn Review comes ahead of the release of another much-anticipated government-commissioned review. Disability and social security minister Stephen Timms has been working with disabled people and organisations which support them to produce a review into the PIP assessment process.

Following Starmer’s U-turn, any changes to PIP were paused until the Timms Review reached a conclusion, with its proposals expected to lead to an overhaul of the disability benefits system.

The Timms Review has already laid out findings showing that the PIP assessment process is “stressful and dehumanising”, and it has set out initial recommendations to reform the system.

These included changes to protect people with fluctuating conditions from reassessment, better communications and processes, and a more targeted and personalised approach. However, while some of these recommendations were welcomed, there remained fear that there was no guarantee that PIP would not be cut again.

Any UK government would be under pressure to cut welfare spending, with the bill expected to increase from £333.8 billion in 2025-26 to £431.3bn by 2031-32, according to Office for Budget Responsibility figures.

However, pensioner spending takes up the largest portion of this, at £161.4bn in 2025/26, almost half of total welfare spending. By comparison, disability benefit spending is £45.3bn.

Burnham has said previously “we’ve got to get really serious as a country” at bringing the welfare bill down, but he also spoke out against Starmer’s plans for PIP cuts and promised his government would take a “different approach”.

In his Labour conference speech, Burnham said: “We will need a fundamental rethink of the welfare system to find the money for these opportunities upfront, and we will require young people to take up the help presented to them, guaranteeing in-work support and not leaving those out of work losing confidence and connection.

“This is a different approach to welfare. It is based on a philosophy of social security, a country which invests in people’s success rather than abandoning them and paying for failure. A country like that would be much more resilient to the shocks we will undoubtedly face in the rest of this century.”

Evidence shows that cutting benefits could have adverse effects of pushing people out of work instead of improving unemployment levels. 

Joseph Rowntree Foundation and Trussell research finds that young people who grew up in persistent poverty were 3.4 times more likely to be out of education, employment or training at 23 than those who had never experienced childhood poverty.

The foundation also found that previous cuts to health-related benefits increased hardship without improving employment outcomes. The 2017 cut to employment and support allowance led to increased risks of severe poverty and poor mental health, with no improvement to the number of people in work.

Joseph Rowntree Foundation researchers argue that “cutting someone’s income when they are already struggling to pay for food or the bus to college risks making it harder to stay in education or find work”.

The health element of universal credit has already been slashed to £217.26 a month for new claimants, around half the amount that current claimants receive. If young people were to lose this money too in a further cut and they were not eligible for PIP, they would have to be reliant on the standard rate of universal credit. 

This is already lower for young people under the age of 25. It is currently £333.58 a month, the equivalent of £78 a week before any deductions, to cover their living costs. This is around £40 a week lower than the amount needed to cover essential costs like food, energy and water bills, and toiletries, according to Joseph Rowntree Foundation estimates.

The charity is calling for the government to instead protect disability benefits and fund specialist employment support which includes one-to-one advice, accessible placements, and help with travel and childcare costs. It doesn’t have to choose between financial security for young people and better employment support, the researchers claim, because they should both be in place.

They also call for the government to raise the basic rate of universal credit so people can afford their essentials, and introduce a protected minimum income floor below which household income cannot fall.

Disability benefit cuts are also a risk to the Burnham government. Under Starmer, the plans to cut benefits led to significant outcry, particularly from Labour MPs who refused to back the proposals and voted against the government. 

Labour MPs have already spoken out against the Milburn proposals. Neil Duncan-Jordan, who was suspended from the Labour Party for rebelling against the government over its welfare proposals last year, has written to Pat McFadden to warn him against the cuts.

“Young disabled people will not cease to be disabled if the support they rely on is withdrawn; they will simply be poorer disabled people,” he said in the letter. 

“Benefit cuts and sanctions do not create jobs, but increase poverty and place greater pressure on the NHS, local councils and other public services – ultimately costing us more in the long run.”



Do you have a story to tell or opinions to share about this? Get in touch and tell us more. 

Change a vendor’s life.

Buy from your local Big Issue vendor every week – and always take the magazine. It’s how vendors earn with dignity and move forward.

You can also support online:
Subscribe to the magazine or support our work with a monthly gift. Your support helps vendors earn, learn and thrive while strengthening our frontline services.

Thank you for standing with Big Issue vendors.

Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty

There’s more than one way to make a difference

Big Issue vendors need you more than ever this Christmas.

Recommended for you

View all
'I don't feel hopeful': Thousands of young women are NEET due to caring as Milburn prepares report
Natalya
Youth unemployment

'I don't feel hopeful': Thousands of young women are NEET due to caring as Milburn prepares report

TikTok is cutting human moderators in favour of AI. Fired workers are fighting back 
Image of a hand holding a phone
Technology

TikTok is cutting human moderators in favour of AI. Fired workers are fighting back 

Young people urgently need a stake in the future. Does the autumn budget deliver it?
Chancellor of the Exchequer John Healey prepares to deliver the Budget at 11 Downing Street
Autumn budget

Young people urgently need a stake in the future. Does the autumn budget deliver it?

'I was homeless and now I'm a tour guide. It's walking and talking - which I'm actually good at!'
Mandy shares historical facts in the gardens of Old Gala House, a 16th-century mansion that’s now a museum
Travel

'I was homeless and now I'm a tour guide. It's walking and talking - which I'm actually good at!'