Advertisement
Housing

Scottish government accused of failing tenants by voting down rent freeze

A Scottish Labour bid to freeze soaring rents for two years was rejected despite warnings that tenants will be pushed into poverty.

Rent campaigners have accused the Scottish government of “failing tenants” after ministers voted down a bid to introduce a rent freeze across Scotland.

MSPs voted against an amendment to the Coronavirus Recovery Bill tabled by Scottish Labour on Tuesday which aimed to freeze rents for two years until rent controls are introduced in 2024.

The move comes as rents have continued to rise to record levels in recent months and have surged 8.5 per cent in Scotland in the last year, according to analysis from CityLets. That includes rises of 16 per cent in Glasgow and 14 per cent in Edinburgh.

Subscribe to The Big Issue

From just £3 per week

Take a print or digital subscription to The Big Issue and provide a critical lifeline to our work.

Labour MSP Mercedes Villalba, who tabled the amendment, insisted the vote means renters risk falling into poverty.

“The SNP-Green government has badly let down Scotland’s renters by using its majority at Holyrood to block a rent freeze,” the North East Scotland MSP told The Big Issue.

“Tenants will now be at the mercy of landlords, who will be free to hike up rents during an ever worsening cost of living crisis.

Advertisement
Advertisement

“Poverty, which is already rife among renters, is likely to get much worse.”

MSPs from the SNP, Scottish Greens and Conservatives all voted against the amendment, which was defeated by 94 votes to 21. 

Deputy prime minister John Swinney said he recognised that some MSPs wanted the government to go further to protect tenants in the bill.

He insisted ministers had maintained some protections in the legislation despite “some calls for those provisions that have supported tenants and prevented evictions to be removed”.

Big Issue Foundation

Donate to support vendors today

Your gift today will mean Big Issue vendors will get the support they need to progress forward in life. You will be supporting vendors in key areas including housing, finance, mental health and employment.

Swinney said: “The Minister for Zero Carbon Buildings, Active Travel and Tenants’ Rights (Green MSP Patrick Harvie) emphasised that we will continue our detailed work with stakeholders to further raise awareness of tenants’ rights, and to explore how we can make better use of existing powers and increase access to rent adjudication, which is key to challenging unfair rent increases.”

Conservative deputy leader Murdo Fraser warned during the debate that more tenancy legislation could “see an even faster exodus of private landlords from the market” leading to further shortages of private rented homes and even higher rents.

Greens housing spokesperson Ariane Burgess also said the amendment was “unworkable” arguing that landlords would evict tenants to raise rents.

But Scottish tenant union Living Rent called for emergency protections to be introduced to protect tenants from rent hikes and evictions as the rising cost of living continues to squeeze household incomes.

Megan Bishop, Living Rent secretary, accused landlords of “pouring petrol on the cost of living crisis” and called on Holyrood to introduce emergency protections. 

Article continues below

“By voting down a rent freeze and failing to come up with any other adequate emergency protections to prevent unaffordable rent increases, the Scottish government has failed tenants,” she said. “The Scottish government needs to introduce protections to prevent unaffordable rent increases or face the ‘tidal wave of evictions’ they warn against, when tenants are forced to leave their home due to rent increases.

“MSP’s need to put aside their political point scoring, take responsibility and regulate landlord’s greed. Though the government has promised rent controls in 2024, this is too far away when tenants need emergency protections to prevent unaffordable rent increases now.”

While rent controls that cap rent rises to below inflation do have the support of the Scottish government, there is less support from the Westminster government citing the impact on investment in the private rented sector and the standard of homes.

But there is plenty of support among the public for rent controls in England with 72 per cent of Brits backing the policy according to an Ipsos poll released this week.

Advertisement

Bigger Issues need bigger solutions

Big Issue Group is creating new solutions through enterprise to unlock opportunities for the 14.5 million people living in poverty to earn, learn and thrive. Big Issue Group brings together our media and investment initiatives as well as a diverse and pioneering range of new solutions, all of which aim to dismantle poverty by creating opportunity. Learn how you can change lives today.

Recommended for you

Read All
The number of children living in temporary accommodation in Scotland surges by almost a fifth
Homelessness

The number of children living in temporary accommodation in Scotland surges by almost a fifth

What is Housing First and how can it solve homelessness in the UK?
Housing

What is Housing First and how can it solve homelessness in the UK?

Buying a home in the UK is more expensive than ever. When will house prices go down?
House Prices

Buying a home in the UK is more expensive than ever. When will house prices go down?

Rents in the UK are rising at the highest rate for decades. Will they keep going up?
Renting

Rents in the UK are rising at the highest rate for decades. Will they keep going up?

Most Popular

Read All
Oil giants Shell and BP have been handed £700m of taxpayer cash despite bumper profits
1.

Oil giants Shell and BP have been handed £700m of taxpayer cash despite bumper profits

What are the risks of Don't Pay UK? We asked a leading lawyer
2.

What are the risks of Don't Pay UK? We asked a leading lawyer

How broken is the UK's public transport? I spent all day on buses to find out
3.

How broken is the UK's public transport? I spent all day on buses to find out

Sadiq Khan's Right to Buy-back scheme leads to return of 1,500 council homes
4.

Sadiq Khan's Right to Buy-back scheme leads to return of 1,500 council homes

Keep up to date with the Big Issue. The leading voice on life, politics, culture and social activism direct to your inbox.