Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty
Social Justice

Tory manifesto: Rishi Sunak slammed for 'arbitrary, untenable and cruel' immigration pledges

With the launch of the Conservatives' manifesto, Sunak has promised to process all asylum claims within six months. Here's what experts think

Rishi Sunak at the Conservative 2024 election manifesto launch

Sunak said he believes in the need for a deterrent against illegal migration. Image: Edward Massey/CCHQ/Flickr

Rishi Sunak’s manifesto promise to halve migration has been slammed as “arbitrary, untenable and cruel” by experts as the Conservatives unveiled the immigration plans at the heart of their election strategy.

The prime minister has said that, if his government is re-elected, parliament will vote each year on a legally-binding cap on migration.

All asylum claims will be processed in six months and the use of hotels ended, the newly-released manifesto promised, while automatically raising the £38,700 threshold for skilled workers and family visas in line with inflation.

“Saying that ‘migration will be halved’ is arbitrary, untenable and cruel,” said Yasmin Halima, executive director at the Joint Centre for the Welfare of Immigrants.

“Instead, any future government should be focussing on how to fix the inefficiencies of an immigration system that leaves traumatised people in limbo, often for years, and that punishes those who come here to study or work. “

Also announced this week, the Lib Dems’ plans include giving asylum seekers the right to work after three months of waiting for a claim, and scrapping the Rwanda scheme.

Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty
Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty

In a speech at Silverstone racetrack, Sunak committed to the Rwanda plan as a deterrent and said migration has been too high in recent years.

Josephine Whitaker-Yilmaz, policy and public affairs manager at Praxis, said the manifesto policies carried on a trend of “intensifying anti-migrant rhetoric”. 

“Unfortunately, what we’ve seen in the Conservative Party manifesto is a doubling down on this theme, with the promise of yet another hike in already exorbitant visa fees to pay for more police,” said Whitaker-Yilmaz. 

Keep reading the journalism that powers our mission

Register free to continue and learn more about the stories, campaigns and the support we provide, helping people facing poverty across the UK.

“Not only would this do nothing to solve the root causes of underinvestment in our public services, it would also exacerbate the growing problem of poverty and homelessness in our communities, including amongst migrant households.”

Net migration to the UK reached 685,000 in 2023, accounted for by a rise in non-EU citizens coming to the UK, according to the Migration Observatory.

New research suggests 63% of Brits think politicians use refugees as a weapon to stoke the ‘culture wars’.

Sunak’s plans were dismissed by migration expert Zoe Gardner. “They are the last gasps of a government that has so spectacularly mismanaged the country as to make their nonsense manifesto almost irrelevant to the election debate at all,” said Gardner. “It’s almost impressive.”

Advertising helps fund Big Issue’s mission to end poverty

There’s more than one way to make a difference

Big Issue vendors need you more than ever this Christmas.

Recommended for you

View all
'I wish I'd smacked Russell Brand's teeth in when I had the chance'
Russell Brand
Sam Delaney

'I wish I'd smacked Russell Brand's teeth in when I had the chance'

What January's £400 energy bills hike means for struggling families: 'Christmas is off the cards'
an old man sat looking sad at the end of his bed
energy bills

What January's £400 energy bills hike means for struggling families: 'Christmas is off the cards'

Don Letts: 'Not voting doesn't mean you're opting out of politics'
Don Letts
PM For The PM

Don Letts: 'Not voting doesn't mean you're opting out of politics'

'Digital hostile environment': How artificial intelligence is secretly changing the Home Office
home secretary Shabana Mahmood
Home Office

'Digital hostile environment': How artificial intelligence is secretly changing the Home Office