It’s that thing that has hit me at a few points in my career: when you talk to somebody and you get this very visceral sense that they are still frightened. That’s what I got when I spoke to Liz. And when you watch how the sequence of events unfolded, it really is like a horror movie come to life.
It’s really clear how much of an impact these events had on Liz and her family. How do you make sure you’re looking after the real people at the core of these stories?
I’m really glad to say that everyone who’s been on Uncanny has had a positive experience out of it. We stay in touch with the vast majority of people. With Liz specifically, on The Witch Farm, we talk regularly. For her, telling this story has been an incredibly positive, therapeutic thing. When you go through those things, you need to talk about them. You need to somehow make sense of this fear. You want to feel vindicated and validated.
Keep reading the journalism that powers our mission
Register free to continue and learn more about the stories, campaigns and the support we provide, helping people facing poverty across the UK.
Read more:
Do you think that ghost sightings perhaps go up when mental health support is cut?
I certainly couldn’t give a definite answer on that, but I know anecdotally that reports of paranormal experience went up a lot during Covid, which is revealing. That was a period when we were haunted by our houses – these previously cosy places became quite claustrophobic and oppressive.
You can look at the booms in paranormal interest post First World War, post Second World War – right back to the Jacobean period, the era of witch hunting and plague and religious division. All these periods when our society is fractured and frightened and uncertain, when our mental health is put to the test, you definitely see booms of paranormal interest. Is that us wanting to find magic in a bleak world? Is it us wanting to try and find answers when there is uncertainty? Or is it literally paranormal activity manifesting?
Has your opinion changed since Uncanny started? Have you become more Team Believer or more Team Sceptic?
Without wanting to sound like a contestant on The X Factor, I feel like I’ve been on a journey. If you listen to me making the very first show I ever did, you hear a more sceptic me. But you can’t be exposed to all of these stories and not have it eat away at your resolve a little bit.
I am someone who loves the idea of ghosts existing. I think the idea that death is not the end is a wonderful idea. And I just love the idea of magic. I do really love the idea that we haven’t discovered everything about our universe and that there’s something more out there, just waiting in the shadows for us. So I really want it to be real, but I haven’t had that experience that pushes me over the edge.
Not for want of trying, right?
I know! Come on, ghosts!
If anyone is going to see a ghost, it seems only fair you should. You’ve done so much for them.
Well, they’re not keeping their end of the bargain. But I do enjoy existing in a state of uncertainty, and I think there’s a lot to be said for being somewhere in the middle. Uncanny would be a very different show if I took a really strong position and pushed an agenda, whether it was belief or scepticism.
I enjoy being torn and listening with an open mind. It’s something that is in short supply in our world. One of the big messages of Uncanny and all of the things I do is: keep an open mind, listen to people and don’t dismiss things too quickly.
The first two episodes of The Witch Farm are on BBC iPlayer from 22 November; the series begins at 9pm that night on BBC One. Uncanny is on BBC Sounds
Do you have a story to tell or opinions to share about this? Get in touch and tell us more.
Change a vendor’s life.
Buy from your local Big Issue vendor every week – and always take the magazine. It’s how vendors earn with dignity and move forward.
You can also support online:
Subscribe to the magazine or support our work with a monthly gift. Your support helps vendors earn, learn and thrive while strengthening our frontline services.
Thank you for standing with Big Issue vendors.