News

'Flawed' Universal Credit algorithm is 'pushing people into poverty'

Human Rights Watch concluded that a “comprehensive redesign” of the automated process is required to “reflect the reality of people’s lives”

EPA/Andy Rain

The technology behind Universal Credit must undergo a “comprehensive redesign”, say human rights campaigners, amid warnings that the algorithm which calculates how much people receive is causing people to go hungry, fall into debt and experience psychological distress.

Campaign group Human Rights Watch also accuses the government of failing to fully address inequalities in access to online services, where people apply for and manage their benefits, in a new report titled report “Automated Hardship: How the Tech-Driven Overhaul of the UK’s Benefits System Worsens Poverty”.

“The government’s bid to automate the benefits system – no matter the human cost – is pushing people to the brink of poverty,” said Amos Toh, senior artificial intelligence and human rights researcher at Human Rights Watch (HRW).

“Making sure the benefits system protects people’s rights is ultimately a job for humans, not an algorithm.”

Universal Credit has proven to be a vital lifeline for many in the face of job losses and redundancies during the Covid-19 pandemic.

Around 3.4 million people turned to the benefit during the coronavirus lockdown between March and June 2020.

The report comes six weeks after the government U-turn on A-level exam results which initially saw tens of thousands of students have their predicted grades demoted by an algorithm.

Universal Credit has been a lifeline for millions in this crisis, but it doesn’t always fit with the reality of people’s lives

Toh continued: “Benefits are designed to help people, not kick them when they’re down. A human-centred approach to benefits automation will ensure the UK government is helping the people who need it most.”

Based on interviews with 35 people carried out between March and July this year, including 14 claiming the controversial benefit, HRW concluded that the means-tested algorithm behind Universal Credit is flawed.

The system is supposed to adjust how much people are entitled to on a monthly basis based on changes in their earnings.

But HRW discovered that the government data only reflects the wages people receive within a calendar month without taking into account how frequently people are paid. Therefore, people who receive multiple payments in one month can see their earnings overestimated and their Universal Credit payment fall as a result.

A spokesperson for the Department of Work and Pensions (DWP) told The Big Issue that the monthly assessment was designed to “mirror the world of work”, a policy in place since the system was first launched in 2013.

It is common for people in irregular or low-paid jobs to receive multiple wages in one month and Universal Credit must reflect “the reality of people’s lives”, says Citizens Advice chief executive Dame Gillian Guy in response to the report.

“Universal Credit has been a lifeline for millions in this crisis, but it doesn’t always fit with the reality of people’s lives,” she said.

“Those in irregular work can find themselves struggling to budget from month to month, while new claimants risk facing hardship or debt while they wait for a first payment.

“With the potential for a fresh avalanche of job losses this winter, it’s critical the government further strengthens the safety net. That means turning advance payments into grants to help people weather the five-week wait and ensuring the system can respond flexibly to people’s circumstances.”

Fixing the problem

A 31-year-old father of three who spoke to the authors said his October 2019 benefit was reduced by nearly £600, and he had to borrow money from his parents and rely on food donations.

“I’ve worked all my life and I am resorting to using the food bank today because of benefits that I am receiving,” the man, whose name is not given, is quoted as saying in the report. “It’s not really a benefit is it, if I’m having to use this service?”

But HRW says the government has failed to act to solve the problem, despite being ordered to do more to rectify the effect on people who receive a regular monthly salary by the UK Appeal Court in June.

The Department of Work and Pensions (DWP) accepted the ruling but is still figuring out how to implement the changes.

HRW suggested the government could switch to shorter income assessment periods, or use averaged earnings over long periods to smooth out the fluctuations in pay from month-to month.

Making sure the benefits system protects people’s rights is ultimately a job for humans, not an algorithm

There also remains a problem with the “digital by default” nature of applying for and managing Universal Credit.

The government has increased funding to support people applying but demand for support outstrips supply according to HRW, particularly as austerity has hit digital services at libraries and community centres.

The UK government’s international human rights obligations require it to secure everyone’s rights to social security and a decent standard of living, write the authors. But they say the UK has failed to put these rights into domestic law and to give those whose rights are violated an effective remedy.

The DWP spokesperson said: “Universal Credit was designed to mirror the world of work, where the majority of employees receive wages monthly, and to help people get back into employment as soon as possible. The monthly assessment and adjustment period reflects this, and ensures that if a claimant’s income falls, they won’t have to wait several months for a rise in their Universal Credit.

“Urgent advances are available for those who need them, and we have taken steps to make debt repayments easier.”

Image: EPA/Andy Rain

Support our vendors this winter and beyond

If you can't visit your local vendor on a regular basis, then the next best way to support them is with a subscription to the Big Issue. As a social enterprise, we invest every penny we make back into the organisation. That means that with every subscription, we are supporting people in poverty to get back on their own two feet.
Vendor martin Hawes

Recommended for you

View all
Why Jeremy Hunt's Spring Budget is the most important in years – and could decide Labour's future
Jeremy Hunt, spring budget
Politics

Why Jeremy Hunt's Spring Budget is the most important in years – and could decide Labour's future

Rising homelessness has UK in a chokehold – but this project is fighting back with mixed martial arts
MMA class to prevent homelessness in Sheffield
Homelessness

Rising homelessness has UK in a chokehold – but this project is fighting back with mixed martial arts

'I miss home so much': Ukrainian refugee on life in UK two years into Russia's bloody war
Ukrainian refugee Luba Bilko, who fled her home near Kyiv in February 2022
Russia-Ukraine war

'I miss home so much': Ukrainian refugee on life in UK two years into Russia's bloody war

UK energy bills to fall – but millions still live in dangerously cold and damp homes
energy bills/ hob
Energy bills

UK energy bills to fall – but millions still live in dangerously cold and damp homes

Most Popular

Read All
Renters pay their landlords' buy-to-let mortgages, so they should get a share of the profits
Renters: A mortgage lender's window advertising buy-to-let products
1.

Renters pay their landlords' buy-to-let mortgages, so they should get a share of the profits

Exclusive: Disabled people are 'set up to fail' by the DWP in target-driven disability benefits system, whistleblowers reveal
Pound coins on a piece of paper with disability living allowancve
2.

Exclusive: Disabled people are 'set up to fail' by the DWP in target-driven disability benefits system, whistleblowers reveal

Here's when UK households to start receiving last cost of living payments
next dwp cost of living payment 2023
3.

Here's when UK households to start receiving last cost of living payments

Strike dates 2023: From train drivers to NHS doctors, here are the dates to know
4.

Strike dates 2023: From train drivers to NHS doctors, here are the dates to know